Setting up close reading
Students start the year reading short stories and articles with care. They learn to back up what they think with specific lines from the text instead of a gut reaction.
This is the year reading and writing turn into argument. Students stop just summarizing what a book or article says and start explaining how the author builds meaning, and why it works. In essays, they learn to defend a position with reasons and proof from the text, not just opinion. By spring, students can write a clear argument paper that backs up each claim with evidence pulled from what they read.
Students start the year reading short stories and articles with care. They learn to back up what they think with specific lines from the text instead of a gut reaction.
Students dig into how a piece of writing is put together and why word choice matters. They notice tone, figurative language, and the way a paragraph or scene is structured.
Students write essays that take a clear position and back it up with reasons and evidence. They also practice informative writing that explains a topic clearly to a reader who is new to it.
Students pick a focused question and pull information from several sources to answer it. They learn to weigh which sources are trustworthy and how to fold outside information into their own writing.
Students read longer and harder texts and compare themes across stories, plays, and poems. They look at how different writers handle a similar idea and what each choice does to the reader.
Students lead and join class discussions where they listen, respond, and build on what others say. They also present findings out loud so a listener can follow the reasoning from start to finish.
Reading a nonfiction article or report closely, then backing up any conclusion with specific lines or details pulled directly from the text. A guess without evidence does not count.
Students read nonfiction articles, essays, and reports to figure out why the author arranged the information that way and how specific word choices shape what the reader takes away.
Students read several articles or sources on the same topic, then weigh what each one says to build a fuller, more accurate picture. The goal is to see where sources agree, where they differ, and what that means together.
Students learn the specific words that show up in textbooks, articles, and academic writing across subjects. When they read about history, science, or current events, they build the vocabulary needed to understand and discuss the material.
Students read and understand complex nonfiction on their own, without help from the teacher. This standard is less about one specific skill and more about whether students can handle challenging real-world reading, like articles, essays, and reports, by themselves.
| Standard | Definition | Code |
|---|---|---|
| Key Ideas and Details Grades 9-10 | Reading a nonfiction article or report closely, then backing up any conclusion with specific lines or details pulled directly from the text. A guess without evidence does not count. | PA-ELA.RI.9-10.1 |
| Craft and Structure Grades 9-10 | Students read nonfiction articles, essays, and reports to figure out why the author arranged the information that way and how specific word choices shape what the reader takes away. | PA-ELA.RI.9-10.2 |
| Integration of Knowledge Grades 9-10 | Students read several articles or sources on the same topic, then weigh what each one says to build a fuller, more accurate picture. The goal is to see where sources agree, where they differ, and what that means together. | PA-ELA.RI.9-10.3 |
| Vocabulary Acquisition Grades 9-10 | Students learn the specific words that show up in textbooks, articles, and academic writing across subjects. When they read about history, science, or current events, they build the vocabulary needed to understand and discuss the material. | PA-ELA.RI.9-10.4 |
| Range of Reading Grades 9-10 | Students read and understand complex nonfiction on their own, without help from the teacher. This standard is less about one specific skill and more about whether students can handle challenging real-world reading, like articles, essays, and reports, by themselves. | PA-ELA.RI.9-10.5 |
Reading closely means students go back into the story or poem to find specific lines that back up their conclusions. They don't just say what happened. They show why they think so, using the actual words on the page.
Students read a story or poem and explain how the author's word choices, structure, and figurative language work together to create a specific mood or meaning.
Students read two or more works side by side and explain how the themes or structures are similar or different. A poem and a novel might wrestle with the same idea but build it in completely different ways.
Students learn to read the emotional weight of word choices in a story or poem, including metaphors, symbols, and the unstated meanings a word carries beyond its dictionary definition.
Students read full-length novels, plays, and poems on their own, working through complex language and ideas without step-by-step help. This is the independent reading stamina built across ninth and tenth grade.
| Standard | Definition | Code |
|---|---|---|
| Key Ideas and Details Grades 9-10 | Reading closely means students go back into the story or poem to find specific lines that back up their conclusions. They don't just say what happened. They show why they think so, using the actual words on the page. | PA-ELA.RL.9-10.1 |
| Craft and Structure Grades 9-10 | Students read a story or poem and explain how the author's word choices, structure, and figurative language work together to create a specific mood or meaning. | PA-ELA.RL.9-10.2 |
| Integration of Knowledge Grades 9-10 | Students read two or more works side by side and explain how the themes or structures are similar or different. A poem and a novel might wrestle with the same idea but build it in completely different ways. | PA-ELA.RL.9-10.3 |
| Vocabulary Acquisition Grades 9-10 | Students learn to read the emotional weight of word choices in a story or poem, including metaphors, symbols, and the unstated meanings a word carries beyond its dictionary definition. | PA-ELA.RL.9-10.4 |
| Range of Reading Grades 9-10 | Students read full-length novels, plays, and poems on their own, working through complex language and ideas without step-by-step help. This is the independent reading stamina built across ninth and tenth grade. | PA-ELA.RL.9-10.5 |
Students write an argument, then back it up with real evidence from sources and explain why that evidence supports their point. The reasoning has to hold up, not just sound convincing.
Students write essays or reports that explain a topic clearly, using facts, details, and examples a reader can follow. The goal is to inform, not to argue.
Students write a story, real or invented, with a clear sequence of events, specific details, and techniques like dialogue or pacing that make the writing hold together and feel alive.
Students work through the full writing process, from planning and drafting to revising and editing, with a clear sense of who they're writing for and why.
Students pick a focused question, gather information from several sources, and weave those findings into a research project. The work applies to both a quick assignment and a longer multi-week project.
Students write with correct grammar, punctuation, capitalization, and spelling. This standard covers the mechanical side of writing: the rules that make a sentence clear and professional.
| Standard | Definition | Code |
|---|---|---|
| Argumentative Writing Grades 9-10 | Students write an argument, then back it up with real evidence from sources and explain why that evidence supports their point. The reasoning has to hold up, not just sound convincing. | PA-ELA.W.9-10.1 |
| Informative or Explanatory Grades 9-10 | Students write essays or reports that explain a topic clearly, using facts, details, and examples a reader can follow. The goal is to inform, not to argue. | PA-ELA.W.9-10.2 |
| Narrative Grades 9-10 | Students write a story, real or invented, with a clear sequence of events, specific details, and techniques like dialogue or pacing that make the writing hold together and feel alive. | PA-ELA.W.9-10.3 |
| Production and Process Grades 9-10 | Students work through the full writing process, from planning and drafting to revising and editing, with a clear sense of who they're writing for and why. | PA-ELA.W.9-10.4 |
| Conducting Research Grades 9-10 | Students pick a focused question, gather information from several sources, and weave those findings into a research project. The work applies to both a quick assignment and a longer multi-week project. | PA-ELA.W.9-10.5 |
| Conventions of Language Grades 9-10 | Students write with correct grammar, punctuation, capitalization, and spelling. This standard covers the mechanical side of writing: the rules that make a sentence clear and professional. | PA-ELA.W.9-10.6 |
Students come to class discussions ready to engage, not just wait their turn to talk. They listen to what classmates say, build on those ideas, and explain their own thinking clearly.
Students organize a spoken presentation so the main point is clear and each piece of evidence connects back to it. Listeners should be able to follow the argument without asking what the point was.
Students pull together information from sources like videos, podcasts, and written texts to build a fuller picture of a topic. They also weigh whether a speaker's argument holds up or reflects a particular bias.
| Standard | Definition | Code |
|---|---|---|
| Comprehension and Collaboration Grades 9-10 | Students come to class discussions ready to engage, not just wait their turn to talk. They listen to what classmates say, build on those ideas, and explain their own thinking clearly. | PA-ELA.SL.9-10.1 |
| Presentation of Knowledge Grades 9-10 | Students organize a spoken presentation so the main point is clear and each piece of evidence connects back to it. Listeners should be able to follow the argument without asking what the point was. | PA-ELA.SL.9-10.2 |
| Integrate Information Grades 9-10 | Students pull together information from sources like videos, podcasts, and written texts to build a fuller picture of a topic. They also weigh whether a speaker's argument holds up or reflects a particular bias. | PA-ELA.SL.9-10.3 |
End-of-course exam in Literature, typically grade 10 or 11.
Students read harder books and articles, then back up what they say about them with specific lines from the text. They write arguments, explanations, and stories, and they take part in real discussions where they have to listen and respond. Most assignments ask for evidence, not just opinions.
Ask them what they are reading and then ask one follow-up question: what makes you think that? Pushing for a line or a moment from the book turns a shrug into real thinking. Even a five-minute conversation at dinner counts.
Talk through the argument out loud before they write. If they can say the claim in one sentence and name two pieces of evidence, the draft gets much easier. Skip grammar fixes until the ideas are settled.
Start with shorter argument and explanation pieces tied to current reading, then build toward longer research writing in the second half. Narrative writing fits well early, when students are still warming up to academic writing. Revision should be part of every cycle, not a one-time event.
Two areas come up every year: picking evidence that actually proves the point, and explaining how the evidence connects to the claim. Vocabulary in context is the other soft spot, especially with denser nonfiction. Plan to revisit all three across units.
Any reading that stretches them helps, including news articles, biographies, and longer magazine pieces. The goal is comfort with harder, slower texts, not a specific book list. Twenty minutes of real reading a few nights a week makes a noticeable difference.
A student can read a complex article or short story on their own and write a clear argument about it, using two or three well-chosen quotes. They can also hold their own in a discussion, building on what someone else said instead of restarting. Grammar and spelling are mostly clean in final drafts.
Look for a student who can finish a longer text without giving up, defend an opinion with specific lines from the page, and revise a draft based on feedback. If those three habits are in place, the jump to the next grade is manageable. If not, focus the summer on independent reading.
Plan for at least one short research project each semester and one longer sustained project across the year. Focused questions matter more than topic size, since a sharp question forces real source evaluation. Build in checkpoints so students do not pile everything into the last week.